What’s the Best Water Heater for Your Needs?

Serving Brooklyn Since 1906

If your traditional water heater is nearing the end of its life cycle, you may be considering whether the time is right to replace it with a tankless version or whether you should stick with a conventional model.

But there are several other factors you should take into consideration when it’s time to replace your family’s source of hot water.

Your house size and family size, as well as your energy goals, are all things you should think about when making your selection. Read on to learn more, or reach out to our Brooklyn plumbers for help!

Size

A Petri Technician smiling after installing a new water heater in a Brooklyn, NY home.

To determine the right size you’ll need for your home, calculate how many people will be using the hot water. A tankless water heater can deliver seven gallons of hot water per minute while a 50-gallon conventional tank heater is usually sufficient for a family of four.

Fuel

Gas or electric models are two options you can consider. Both conventional and tankless water heaters can be powered by either of these fuel types. But, you can also consider a solar heater that uses the sun to warm the water.

Energy efficiency

While both tankless and traditional water heaters have improved throughout the years to provide more energy efficiency, those that are approved by ENERGY STAR can save up to 50% in annual energy use. The Department of Energy estimates that a tankless water heater can be 24% to 34% more efficient than their conventional cousins.

Cost

Finally, you should consider how much you want to spend a year operating your new water heater. An electric water heater costs about $450 a year to operate while a gas-powered model costs about $250 a year.

There are other things you should consider when selecting a new water heater and both traditional and tankless have their pros and cons. If you want lower installation costs but don’t mind a less energy-efficient water heater, a conventional model may be right for you. But, if you prefer a longer lifespan and additional space, you may need to look at the tankless versions.

Either way, your Brooklyn plumbing experts at Petri Plumbing, Heating, Cooling & Drain Cleaning, Heating, Cooling & Drain Cleaning can help you make the right selection for your home, family size and objectives. Give us a call today to schedule a consultation.

Need Help?

We’re open 24/7, call today or schedule online now!
4.7 Stars | 1075+ Google Reviews
Fred T. Milani
Fred T. Milani
5 days ago via Google

We can’t say enough about the great job that Will did clearing out our clogged tub drain…after trying to snake it out and having no luck, he used the water blaster (?) and kept trying and finally succeeded…Will was great!👍

Zondwayo Mulwanda
Zondwayo Mulwanda
1 week ago via Google

Great experience with Petri! Started with Faison who came earlier in week and gave me estimate and did some quick fixes for free. Then Josue and Will came to replace my water heater. They walked me through the process , tagged all my plumbing for me and let me record videos to

Lukas A
Lukas A
2 weeks ago via Google

I got to admit. Joseph Fantasia is the goat. Got my hvac crisp in minutes on a hot summer day.

Contact Us Today

Ready for top-notch plumbing or HVAC service in New York? Look no further. Petri Plumbing, Heating, Cooling & Drain Cleaning has been the trusted plumber and HVAC company New York homeowners have relied on since 1906. Whether you’re dealing with a plumbing emergency, a heating issue, or need a new cooling system installed, our team is ready to help across Brooklyn, Queens and Manhattan. Same-day appointments are often available. Fill out the form below or call us now to get on the schedule today.

Petri then in 1906 and now

A Century of Brooklyn Grit, Heart, and Craftsmanship

For over 100 years, Petri has been more than a plumbing company—it’s been a living legacy passed down through four generations of hardworking Brooklynites. What started as a donkey-cart operation run by two brothers-in-law has grown into one of the city’s most respected service companies—built not just on craftsmanship, but on character. Four generations later, the tools have changed, but the values haven’t. Through snowstorms, blackouts, and busted boilers, the Petri family has always found a way—and always will.

READ OUR FULL STORY